Justice secretary to fulfill Sentencing Council after it refuses to again down over alleged ‘differential remedy’ guidelines
Ministers have revived their risk to legislate to curb the powers of the Sentencing Council after it refused the federal government’s request to withdraw tips allegedly beneficial to minorities.
Talking on behalf of the federal government on the morning interview spherical, Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, mentioned the federal government didn’t assist “differential treatment” and that it might legislate to get its method if crucial.
He additionally mentioned Shabana Mahmood, the justice secretary, could be assembly the Sentencing Council on Thursday to debate the stand-off.
The council, which is unbiased of presidency, printed the brand new tips final week after a protracted session interval throughout which the final authorities, and the present authorities, raised no objections to what was being proposed. However, after the Tories claimed the brand new tips would quantity to “two-tier justice”, Mahmood in impact mentioned she agreed, and he or she referred to as for the rules to be withdrawn.
Yesterday the council replied with a letter saying it was “completely wrong” to say the brand new tips will result in sentencing coverage favouring minorities. It mentioned some minority ethnic offenders obtain harsher sentences than equal white offenders, and the brand new tips would make the system fairer.
In his letter Lord Justice William Davis, chair of the council, prompt that on this case the justice secretary doesn’t have the authorized energy to name for sentening tips to be revised as a result of they’ve solely simply been printed, following session along with her division. He mentioned he could be taking authorized recommendation to make clear this.
And, if the federal government tried altering the regulation to present itself powers to rewrite the rules, it might be undermining the unbiased of the judiciary, he prompt.
However Pennycook implied the federal government is keen to vary the regulation anyway to get the principles modified. Requested concerning the story, he instructed LBC:
We’ve been very clear on our place on this matter. We expect everybody’s equal earlier than the regulation. We don’t agree with differential remedy, no matter anybody’s background, and the justice secretary has made her views very well-known.
We don’t agree with the coverage. We’ve requested the Sentencing Council to rethink and rescind the steerage. They’ve clearly replied to the justice secretary yesterday night. She has a gathering with him later this week the place she’ll press her case.
However we’ve been very clear that we received’t hesitate to behave by way of laws if required.
Key occasions
Round a 3rd of Reform UK voters suppose the celebration could be doing higher if Nigel Farage had been changed as chief, a YouGov ballot suggests.
33% of Reform UK voters really feel the celebration could be doing higher if Nigel Farage was now not chief
Could be doing higher beneath totally different chief: 33% of Reform UK voters
Could be doing worse beneath totally different chief: 34%
Neither higher nor worse: 25% pic.twitter.com/Spi3PKSQGk— YouGov (@YouGov) March 11, 2025
Israel blocking provide of tents and sleeping luggage to Gaza on grounds they’re ‘twin use’, MPs instructed
The Israeli authorities has been instructed that it has obligations beneath worldwide humanitarian regulation to permit free and unimpeded entry to assist to Gaza, a Overseas Workplace minister has mentioned.
As PA Media stories, Hamish Falconer instructed the overseas affairs committee this morning that “limited progress” had been made in urging the Israeli authorities to elevate “far-reaching” restrictions with the intention to assist individuals take care of colder situations in winter.
He mentioned that Israel had claimed that some gadgets had been “dual use”, that means they might be used for each civilian and army functions. This consists of tents “because the claim is that the poles could be used as weaponry”, sleeping luggage “because they’re said to be in camouflage colours,” and water purification items “because there’s some fear that they could be used for some other purpose”.
Falconer mentioned:
The character of the dual-use restrictions that Israel has imposed have been so far-reaching as to make … offering the help required to assist individuals reply to the colder situations of winter very, very troublesome certainly.
It was a query very a lot on our minds as winter got here in Gaza, and it was a difficulty on which we made restricted progress.
Requested whether or not he may affirm it had been “impressed upon the Israeli government that they have an obligation under international humanitarian law to allow the free and unimpeded access of aid to Gaza,” he mentioned: “I can.”
Tories affirm they’d assist laws to curb powers of Sentencing Council
In an interview with Sky Information, Andrew Griffith, the shadow enterprise secretary, mentioned the Conservatives would assist the federal government if it determined to vary the regulation to drive the Sentencing Council to withdraw its alleged “differential treatment” guidelines. (See 10.56am.) He mentioned:
I don’t wish to stay in a world the place ministers are deciding any particular person sentence, to be clear. However total coverage, the stability between rights, the values that we have now in society, is the area of elected politicians.
And admittedly, I need if it wants laws, then we’ll assist that. However it ought to by no means have gotten to this.
Requested about stories confirming that Gareth Bacon, a justice minister within the final Conservative authorities, accepted the rules that his celebration is now opposing, Griffith claimed that a lot of ministers and officers had been concerned within the choice. He mentioned he was blaming “a system that needs fundamental reform” as a result of arms-length our bodies just like the Sentencing Council had an excessive amount of energy.
Ousted Reform MP Rupert Lowe may be part of breakaway rightwing celebration
The ousted Reform UK MP Rupert Lowe may be part of forces in a breakaway rightwing celebration with a former deputy chief of the celebration who was additionally compelled out by Nigel Farage, Jessica Elgot and Ben Quinn report.
Justice secretary to fulfill Sentencing Council after it refuses to again down over alleged ‘differential remedy’ guidelines
Ministers have revived their risk to legislate to curb the powers of the Sentencing Council after it refused the federal government’s request to withdraw tips allegedly beneficial to minorities.
Talking on behalf of the federal government on the morning interview spherical, Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, mentioned the federal government didn’t assist “differential treatment” and that it might legislate to get its method if crucial.
He additionally mentioned Shabana Mahmood, the justice secretary, could be assembly the Sentencing Council on Thursday to debate the stand-off.
The council, which is unbiased of presidency, printed the brand new tips final week after a protracted session interval throughout which the final authorities, and the present authorities, raised no objections to what was being proposed. However, after the Tories claimed the brand new tips would quantity to “two-tier justice”, Mahmood in impact mentioned she agreed, and he or she referred to as for the rules to be withdrawn.
Yesterday the council replied with a letter saying it was “completely wrong” to say the brand new tips will result in sentencing coverage favouring minorities. It mentioned some minority ethnic offenders obtain harsher sentences than equal white offenders, and the brand new tips would make the system fairer.
In his letter Lord Justice William Davis, chair of the council, prompt that on this case the justice secretary doesn’t have the authorized energy to name for sentening tips to be revised as a result of they’ve solely simply been printed, following session along with her division. He mentioned he could be taking authorized recommendation to make clear this.
And, if the federal government tried altering the regulation to present itself powers to rewrite the rules, it might be undermining the unbiased of the judiciary, he prompt.
However Pennycook implied the federal government is keen to vary the regulation anyway to get the principles modified. Requested concerning the story, he instructed LBC:
We’ve been very clear on our place on this matter. We expect everybody’s equal earlier than the regulation. We don’t agree with differential remedy, no matter anybody’s background, and the justice secretary has made her views very well-known.
We don’t agree with the coverage. We’ve requested the Sentencing Council to rethink and rescind the steerage. They’ve clearly replied to the justice secretary yesterday night. She has a gathering with him later this week the place she’ll press her case.
However we’ve been very clear that we received’t hesitate to behave by way of laws if required.
General power payments will solely must rise by between 80p and £1.50 per 12 months to fund pylons low cost scheme, says minister
Yesterday the federal government introduced that, beneath measures within the planning and infrastructure invoice, individuals dwelling close to new electrical energy pylons, or different new energy infrastructure, might be given £250 a 12 months off their power payments.
In an interview with Occasions Radio this morning, Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, mentioned this low cost scheme would imply total payments for shoppers being a bit increased than they in any other case could be. However he mentioned it might simply imply common payments going up by between 80p and £1.50 per 12 months. He mentioned:
[The discount scheme] might be put as an obligation on power suppliers, and might be made up within the payments of households throughout the nation. However we’re speaking extraordinarily small quantities. We count on between 80p and £1.50 per 12 months.
And over the long term, as a result of we’re deploying extra renewable power, extra homegrown, clear power, the price of everybody’s payments will come down.
Ben Quinn
Ben Quinn is a senior Guardian reporter.
Rupert Lowe’s seven-strong group at Westminster and his constituency workplace have put out an announcement in their very own names to again him and declare that processes designed to guard employees had been “weaponised” in a “malicious fashion.” They’re defending the MP after he was suspended by Reform UK over alleged misconduct – allegations that Lowe claims have been contrived as a result of he poses a political risk to the celebration’s chief, Nigel Farage.
An announcement within the title of the 5 employees in parliament and two in Lowe’s constituency workplace of Nice Yarmouth was posted on the MP’s X account this morning.
In it, the employees mentioned that they had felt obliged to take the weird step of publishing the assertion and that their employer had no involvement in organising or drafting it.
Describing Lowe as a “decent, and honest man,” they mentioned that wider allegations of bullying had been unfaithful. They mentioned:
We’re all uncomfortable to see processes designed to guard employees weaponised in such an disagreeable and malicious trend.
Not simply tarnishing Rupert’s title unfairly, but in addition our workplace and subsequently us. No one from Reform has ever raised these issues, or any about Rupert, with any of us earlier than this ‘investigation’. In the event that they had been so involved about Rupert’s behaviour why had been we not warned?
Housing minister Matthew Pennycook rejects declare that planning reforms designed to penalise farmers
Good morning. The federal government’s planning and infrastructure invoice is being printed later immediately, and in an article for the Occasions Angela Rayner, the deputy PM and housing secretary, claims will probably be “a major step forward in getting Britain building again”. The measures within the laws have already been properly publicised and Rayner sums them up like this.
A brand new street for Norwich was set to make life simpler for 44,000 owners, rushing up journeys to East Anglia’s greatest hospital and creating 33,000 new jobs. However it was delayed by spurious authorized challenges for 2 years till the case was dismissed as having no logical foundation. This authorities gave it the inexperienced gentle final week.
The numerous organisations that have to be consulted within the planning course of are additionally placing up pointless obstacles. A row over balls hit from a cricket membership has delayed 139 new flats in Bradford. The anticipate a growth consent order elevated by 65 per cent between 2012 and 2021. It now takes round 4 years to get a choice on main infrastructure.
That may change, due to our new planning and infrastructure invoice. As a part of our Plan for Change, we’re fast-tracking choices for greater than 150 main infrastructure tasks this parliament …
We’ll streamline session necessities for tasks resembling roads and railway traces whereas holding them sturdy. Wind and photo voltaic tasks might be prioritised for grid connections, serving to us obtain clear energy by 2030, with these dwelling inside 500 metres of latest pylons given as much as £250 a 12 months off their electrical energy payments.
And we’re fixing a system that each stops growth going forward and fails to guard our habitats and species. Builders can pay right into a Nature Restoration Fund which Pure England specialists can use to realize higher outcomes.
The invoice itself might be printed later immediately.
Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, has been giving interviews this morning to market it, and he has had to reply to a recent line of assault from opponents of the laws that has made the Telegraph splash. The federal government has been saying for a while that it needs to present councils in England the powers to amass land for housebuilding through obligatory buy orders (CPOs) at market costs with out having to pay “hope value” – what the land could be value assuming planning permission for housing had been granted. The Telegraph story presents this as a recent Labour assault on farmers. It quotes Tim Bonner from the Countryside Alliance as saying:
We’ve got been supportive of lots of the Authorities’s adjustments to planning coverage, however giving councils extra energy to cut back the worth of land is a step too far, particularly within the context of such a difficult outlook for farmers and the inheritance tax fiasco.
This isn’t about individuals blocking growth, it’s concerning the state paying the market value for land. We’d like extra homes and extra financial growth, however not at the price of fundamental ideas.
In his interviews Pennycook didn’t problem the info of the story. He instructed LBC the federal government was giving councils the facility to disapply “hope value” in a obligatory buy acquisition “where there’s a site with a significant public interest involved, higher affordable levels of housing, for example, or health and education facilities”. However he mentioned this was not geared toward farmers.
We’re clearly and really clearly not getting down to goal agricultural land. The land use framework we’re consulting on presently will be sure that prime agricultural land is protected, and meals safety is protected.
I see this energy being utilized in explicit, to a lot better impact – and that’s the place I wish to see it come ahead – particularly in city areas, on beforehand developed brownfield land the place regeneration tasks with a major public curiosity might be unlocked extra simply.
When he was requested to confess that the Telegraph was proper to say farmers might be affected, Pennycook mentioned he didn’t suppose the Telegraph was proper – “and it’s not often right, I must say” – as a result of the ultimate choice would relaxation with the native authority. Ministers wouldn’t be saying that prime agricultural land needs to be offered, he mentioned.
Requested about the identical subject on the At present programme, Pennycook mentioned that he was “somewhat mystified that the Telegraph have looked through our CPO powers through the lens of farmers and prime agricultural land” when he anticipated them for use largely “for regeneration projects on previously developed brownfield land in urban centres”.
Right here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Keir Starmer to chair cupboard.
11.30am: Shabana Mahmood, the justice secretary, takes questions within the Commons.
11.30am: Downing Road holds a foyer briefing.
After 12.30pm: MPs begin debating the remaining levels of the employment rights invoice.
If you wish to contact me, please submit a message beneath the road or message me on social media. I can’t learn all of the messages BTL, however should you put “Andrew” in a message geared toward me, I’m extra prone to see it as a result of I seek for posts containing that phrase.
If you wish to flag one thing up urgently, it’s best to make use of social media. You’ll be able to attain me on Bluesky at @andrewsparrowgdn. The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X however particular person Guardian journalists are there, I nonetheless have my account, and should you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I’ll see it and reply if crucial.
I discover it very useful when readers level out errors, even minor typos. No error is just too small to right. And I discover your questions very attention-grabbing too. I can’t promise to answer to all of them, however I’ll attempt to reply to as many as I can, both BTL or generally within the weblog.