Reform of joint enterprise legal guidelines might help to resolve the disaster going through the justice system, a overview of the prison courts has been advised by specialists.
Lord chancellor Shabana Mahmood launched the unbiased, “once in a generation” inquiry into prison courts in December, searching for “bold thinking” on tackling the document crown courtroom caseload.
Two authorized campaigners, Keir Monteith KC and Prof Eithne Quinn, of the College of Manchester, have since advised the overview – led by Sir Brian Leveson – that “considering the overuse of joint enterprise” will “enhance fairness” and assist deal with the backlog of prosecutions.
Joint enterprise legislation permits somebody to be charged with one other individual’s crime whether it is believed that they foresaw it and supposed to encourage or help them.
Black defendants are 16 instances extra prone to be prosecuted underneath the precept than white defendants, CPS knowledge from 2023 revealed, fuelling considerations that racial bias results in teams of bystanders being held collectively liable for crimes dedicated by people.
The result of the trial of seven black youngsters accused of killing Deshaun James-Tuitt, 15, in 2022, has added to considerations.
Prosecutors advised the jury they might not say who had stabbed the London schoolboy however alleged that “all those who travelled to the park” the place it occurred collectively “share responsibility … at the very least, contributing to the force of numbers”.
Nonetheless this month, after a trial lasting 4 months, six of the defendants had been acquitted by jurors and just one, who faces sentence in April, was discovered responsible.
Gerwyn Clever, who defended an adolescent who was 15 on the time of the homicide and spent 14 months on remand earlier than being cleared, mentioned the decision was yet one more instance of the “dangerous scope” of joint enterprise.
Monteith, who led Clever within the case, mentioned the “adverse impact” on their exonerated shopper was “incalculable”, including that holding bystanders liable for what was “sadly an unplanned, spontaneous stabbing” dedicated by a person had “delayed justice”.
Of their submission to the overview led by Leveson, who mentioned the “real difficulties facing the criminal justice system” wanted revolutionary options, Monteith and Quinn mentioned racial bias contributes to pressure on the system by “amplifying” charging and conviction charges by joint enterprise prosecutions.
Final 12 months Stephen Parkinson, the director of public prosecutions, admitted to “racial disparities” within the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS)’s decision-making after it emerged that minority ethnic defendants had been extra prone to be charged for a similar offence than white defendants.
Monteith and Quinn additionally raised considerations to Leveson’s overview about “rap evidence”, comparable to drill lyrics, being utilized in prosecutions in opposition to younger black males.
after publication promotion
Final month, a Manchester pupil’s conviction was quashed, after he spent three years in jail, having been wrongly recognized and labelled a gang member from a video through which drill music was performed.
Nadia Whittome, Labour MP for Nottingham East, is tabling a invoice to make sure that when rap proof is utilized in courtroom “it’s relevant, reliable evidence for crime, and its value isn’t outweighed by the prejudices it might cause”.
She advised the Guardian the difficulty had “massive overlap” with joint enterprise, which additionally wanted to be “seriously reformed”, to “enshrine in law that a person can only be prosecuted under [the principle] where they are proven to have significantly contributed to a crime”.
A CPS spokesperson mentioned it “carefully monitors joint enterprise prosecutions, with senior legal oversight over every case to ensure that our approach is fair and proportionate”.
The CPS is reviewing its steering on how drill music is used, and has applied a nationwide joint enterprise monitoring scheme anticipated to report this 12 months.
