More individuals have gone to a poll field in 2024 than in some other yr in human historical past. Billions have forged votes throughout scores of nations, together with among the largest, strongest democracies on Earth.
However America’s stays the world’s international election, probably the most forensically examined, probably the most consequential all around the world. America issues.
“The US is still the most powerful actor in the international system,” Dr Michael Fullilove, govt director of the Lowy Institute, advised the Guardian this week. “It is the richest company, with the biggest military, the biggest economy.
“It is the only country that runs a truly global foreign policy, the only country that can project power anywhere on Earth.
“It is the democratic, meritocratic superpower … it still attracts so many people around the world … the whole world is remarkably well-informed about the US election.”
And Australia’s future is sure up in America’s electoral choice. As one among America’s closest allies – supporters would possibly argue for “staunchest”, opponents would possibly declare “uncritical” – Australia’s financial, safety and multilateral panorama is tied to that of the US and the occupant of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
How might the election of a second Donald Trump presidency impression Australia? Or how would possibly the quasi-continuity of Vice-President Kamala Harris ascending to the White Home?
Trump, neccesarily, is the item of a lot of Australia’s focus. Harris, as Joe Biden’s vice-president, is the continuity candidate – selling coverage positions in step with the present administration – which means a Trump victory would increase many extra questions.
The election too, shall be keenly fought over a number of home points which don’t have any direct – although some peripheral – impression on Australia. This contains points corresponding to reproductive rights (the overturning of Roe v Wade by the supreme courtroom and a mooted nationwide abortion ban), migration (significantly on the nation’s southern border), gun management and regulation and order – points excluded on this piece.
Watching the crescendo of an more and more vituperative election marketing campaign, Fullilove stated that politically “America is running a high temperature at the moment”.
“My real hope for the election is that there is a clear result, that the loser accepts defeat, that the transfer of power is peaceful – that might sound like a low bar – but it is critical, for America and for the world.”
Values and democracy
Responding to the unpredictability of Trump’s first presidency, Australian politicians repeated the chorus that the Australian-US alliance runs deeper than a president or prime minister and that it’s one based on shared values and democratic rules.
Trump has stated he wouldn’t be a dictator, “except on day one”. He stated he would search retribution on his political opponents: “root out the communists, Marxists, fascists and the radical left thugs that live like vermin within the confines of our country that lie and steal and cheat on elections”.
As commander-in-chief, he stated he would think about using the army to assault home enemies: “It should be very easily handled by, if necessary, by the national guard, or if really necessary, by the military”.
Trump’s former chief of workers, Gen John Kelly, stated this week Trump was a “fascist” who “certainly prefers the dictator approach to government”. Trump has repeatedly lied that he received the 2020 election and mused on “terminating” the structure.
He advised a rally in July that if he was elected president once more, “you won’t have to vote any more”.
“In four years, you don’t have to vote again. We’ll have it fixed so good, you’re not going have to vote.”
Harris has denounced Trump as a “fascist” who needs “unchecked power” and a army personally loyal to him.
In her speech to the Democratic Nationwide Conference, she cited the supreme courtroom’s break up choice in July stating Trump loved broad immunity for official acts taken whereas in workplace.
“Consider the power he [Trump] will have, especially after the United States supreme court ruled he will be immune from prosecution,” she stated. “Imagine Donald Trump with no guardrails.”
Local weather
Local weather change is “one of the greatest scams of all time”, Trump stated final month. “We will drill, baby, drill,” he advised the Republican Nationwide Conference when accepting the celebration’s nomination. “We will do it at levels that nobody’s ever seen before.”
He has stated he would prohibit, by govt order, all offshore wind initiatives on the primary day of his presidency, saying they kill whales.
In his first time period, Trump withdrew from the Paris settlement (the US rejoined beneath Biden). However his marketing campaign has indicated a second Trump presidency would possibly re-abandon the Paris settlement, in addition to the United Nations Framework Conference on Local weather Change (UNFCCC) which underpins it. 198 international locations have dedicated to the UNFCCC: none has left it.
The withdrawal of the US – the world’s second-largest greenhouse fuel emitter and the nation that has contributed the biggest share of historic emissions – would improve political uncertainty across the transition to internet zero and deter funding. It will weaken the affect of the so-called umbrella group – of which Australia is a member – and provides succour to local weather laggards, such because the petrostates, to additional gradual international discount efforts.
Some have argued that a lot of the impetus and funding for international emissions reductions is locked in and emissions reductions efforts are engaged on timescales far longer than a four-year presidential cycle.
However Michael Mann, distinguished professor of meteorology at Pennsylvania State College, has argued “a second Trump term is game over for the climate”.
Harris has referred to as local weather change an “existential threat”. As lawyer normal in California, she prosecuted oil corporations for breaches of environmental legal guidelines. As vice-president, she was the tie-breaking vote within the Senate to go the Inflation Discount Act, which supplied about US$370bn to scale back greenhouse fuel emissions to 40% under 2005 ranges by 2030.
However throughout Harris’s vice-presidency, the US produced and exported probably the most crude oil of any nation at any time in historical past, based on the US Power Info Administration’s figures. Crude oil manufacturing averaged 12.9m barrels a day in 2023, breaking the earlier international report of 12.3m, set in 2019.
Commerce and the financial system
Trump is a fierce financial nationalist, hostile to free commerce and intensely targeted on America’s commerce deficit, which he regards as an indication of weak spot. He has pledged to impose a ten% tariff on all imports to the US, with a 60% tariff on all Chinese language imports and a 100% tariff on Chinese language vehicles.
Economists argue the coverage will result in greater costs and decrease progress. The nonpartisan Peterson Institute for Worldwide Economics estimated the proposed tariffs would decrease the incomes of a median American family by US$1,700 a yr: poor People can be extra affected than the wealthy.
In September, Trump stated: “Together, we will deliver low taxes, low regulations, low energy costs, low interest rates and low inflation so that everyone can afford groceries, a car and a home”. He has promised to scale back regulation and minimize taxes, however some economists argue his tax cuts would profit America’s wealthiest whereas hurting the poorest.
Australia will not be depending on direct commerce with the US, however the majority of Australia’s commerce is with China. If China’s financial system, already weak, is broken additional by a commerce conflict with America, Australia shall be uncovered.
Harris has criticised Trump’s tariff insurance policies, arguing they’d act as a “sales tax on Americans” and result in greater costs and inflation. However the Biden administration – of which she has been vice-president – has prolonged Trump-era tariffs and used tariffs to affect commerce on industries it sees as strategic – significantly in relation to China. The administration prolonged tariffs on photo voltaic panels in 2022, and in Could this yr, elevated tariffs on Chinese language electrical autos to 100%.
As a senator, Harris opposed the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a free commerce settlement (involving Australia) negotiated by President Obama and from which Trump withdrew.
Defence and Aukus
Whereas Trump has been essential of Nato, he has not criticised Australia as a army ally or the Aukus deal, a tripartite settlement (between the US, UK, and Australia) for Australia to amass as much as eight nuclear-powered submarines between now and the mid-2050s, the primary within the 2030s.
Australia’s deputy prime minister, Richard Marles, stated his authorities believed Trump would honour the settlement: “Every engagement we’ve had with the Trump camp in the normal process of speaking with people on both sides of politics in America, there is support for … Aukus,” he stated.
However John Bolton, Trump’s former nationwide safety adviser – now a fierce critic of the previous president – stated of Aukus: “I think it could be in jeopardy”.
Fullilove requested Trump’s vice-presidential candidate JD Vance this yr for his place on the settlement. Vance replied he was “a fan of Aukus”.
“I suspect that Aukus would be safe under Trump too,” Fullilove advised the Guardian.
“Australia is an example of an ally that is contributing to deterrence and contributing to the US industrial base. You could imagine Trump threatening to unpick it, but my conclusion is it is safe.”
Aukus was signed by the Biden-Harris administration. The administration’s Indo-Pacific technique commits to the deal, however doesn’t give a timeline: “Through the Aukus partnership, we will identify the optimal pathway to deliver nuclear-powered submarines to the Royal Australian Navy at the earliest achievable date.”
Airbases in Australia had been used for US airstrikes on Houthi targets in Yemen this month. The defence division confirmed Australia supplied help for the US strikes “through access and overflight for US aircraft in northern Australia”.
after e-newsletter promotion
Israel-Gaza
Each Trump and Harris have declared their help for Israel and reiterated help for a two-state answer between Israel and Palestine.
The US continues to produce Israel with billions of {dollars} of weapons and munitions as Israel carries out its bombardment of Gaza, Lebanon, and, this week, strikes on Iran.
The US is, by far, the biggest provider of arms to Israel: 69% of Israel’s imports of main typical arms between 2019 and 2023 got here from America, based on the Stockholm Worldwide Peace Analysis Institute. The US has signed an settlement to present Israel with $3.8bn in annual army support beneath a 10-year-agreement.
1,200 Israelis died within the 7 October 2023 assaults by Hamas. Greater than 42,000 individuals have died in Gaza since, together with greater than 16,000 youngsters.
Trump has expressed his help for Israel’s invasion and bombardment of Gaza. He has additionally urged Israel to “finish up” the conflict as a result of it’s shedding help.
“You have to finish up your war … you’ve got to get it done,” he advised Israeli newspaper Israel Hayom. “We’ve got to get to peace. You can’t have this going on, and I will say Israel has to be very careful because you are losing a lot of the world. You are losing a lot of support.”
Trump stated of Harris: “She hates Israel. If she’s president, I believe that Israel will not exist within two years from now.”
In his first time period, Trump launched a peace proposal he referred to as a blueprint for a two-state answer: it wouldn’t have created an impartial Palestinian state and was seen as strongly favouring Israel.
“Israel has a right to defend itself,” Harris stated in September’s presidential debate.
She continued: “How it does so matters. Because it is also true far too many innocent Palestinians have been killed. Children. Mothers. What we know is that this war must end. It must end immediately, and the way it will end is we need a ceasefire deal and we need the hostages out.”
Harris has constantly reiterated help for a two-state answer.
The conflict in Ukraine
Practically three years on since Russia invaded Ukraine – and a decade since its preliminary assault on Crimea – the US stays the biggest backer of Ukraine’s conflict effort. It’s by far the one greatest contributor of cash and materiel, outspending the subsequent largest contributor, Germany, by 5 to 1.
Trump has made it abundantly clear he needs the conflict over – or, extra exactly, he needs to cease paying for it.
He advised a rally: “I think [Ukrainian president Volodymyr] Zelenskyy is maybe the greatest salesman of any politician that’s ever lived. Every time he comes to our country he walks away with $US60bn.”
Influencing Republican allies in Congress, Trump stalled the final funding package deal from passing for months whereas Ukrainian forces – critically in need of ammunition and artillery – struggled to carry again Russian advances. Trump’s manoeuvring was criticised as basically backing Vladimir Putin’s irredentism.
Trump has additionally repeatedly claimed if re-elected he would finish the conflict in a day – “I’ll have that done in 24 hours” – with out detailing how. It’s presumed a deal to cease the battle would contain the ceding of Ukrainian territory to Russia.
Trump’s disposition in direction of Ukraine has broader implications for the collective safety precept underpinning Nato. Trump has in contrast Nato to a safety racket and stated he wouldn’t shield “delinquent” allies.
“In fact, I would encourage them [the Russians] to do whatever the hell they want. You gotta pay! You gotta pay your bills.”
Trump has repeatedly upbraided European international locations for failing to stay as much as their dedication to spend 2% of their GDP on defence.
Harris has pledged to proceed Biden’s help for Ukraine and for the Nato alliance. She stated as vice-president “I helped mobilise a global response – over 50 countries – to defend against Putin’s aggression.
“And as president, I will stand strong with Ukraine and our Nato allies.”
Harris, nonetheless, has wavered on Ukraine being admitted as a member to Nato, saying the query was among the many “issues that we will deal with if and when it arrives at that point”.
China
“Trump and Kamala Harris are two bowls of poison for Beijing. Both see China as a competitor or even an adversary,” Prof Zhao Minghao, from the Institute of Worldwide Research at Fudan College, advised the Monetary Occasions.
Trump was hawkish in direction of China in his first time period, confronting Beijing over what he argued had been a set of unfair practices and abuses corresponding to mental property theft, foreign money manipulation and financial espionage. He pledged to “completely eliminate dependence on China in all critical areas,” together with electronics, metal, prescription drugs, and uncommon earths. And he has flagged new legal guidelines to cease US corporations from investing in China and a ban on federal contracts for any firm that outsources to China.
His first administration rejected Chinese language territorial claims within the South China Sea, condemning Beijing’s “campaign of bullying” of different international locations.
Harris spoke on China in September, saying her authorities would work to make sure the US “is leading the world in the industries of the future and making sure America, not China, wins the competition for the 21st century”.
“China is not moving slowly … if we are to compete, we can’t afford to, either.”
She condemned Trump as having “constantly got played by China” and stated his administration shipped superior semiconductors to China, permitting them to improve their army.
“I will never hesitate to take swift and strong measures when China undermines the rules of the road at the expense of our workers, our communities, and our companies.”
The Pacific
Local weather change is an pressing existential risk for the islands of the Pacific. Trump doesn’t point out the local weather disaster in his platform, neither is it talked about in Agenda47.
The Heritage Basis – the conservative thinktank behind the Trump-linked Mission 2025 – has urged for partnership with the Pacific islands, however on American phrases and in its pursuits. “The US must adopt a clear-eyed approach about putting American interests and objectives in the Pacific islands first,” it stated.
The Biden-Harris administration have held two Pacific islands-US summits which have been huge on ambition – with commitments of greater than $1bn to resilience regionalism and sustainable improvement – however seen as missing, to date, in utility and outcomes.
The 2022 US-Pacific partnership declared a shared imaginative and prescient for “a resilient Pacific region of peace, harmony, security, social inclusion, and prosperity”.
Fullilove stated whereas Harris sits inside the mainstream traditions of US overseas coverage over current a long time, “it’s hard to get a really accurate fix on what she thinks about the world”.
“At a broad level, she believes in American leadership, she believes in alliances, she prefers democracy to dictators, she more pro-trade than Trump. But beyond that, it’s very hard to know how she will approach Asia, the part of the world Australia is in, because she hasn’t been a prominent foreign policy voice in the Biden administration.”
Learn extra concerning the 2024 US presidential election:
