Warning: this story incorporates descriptions of self-harm and a few readers would possibly discover it distressing.
A staggering 57 Australians have killed themselves previously 20 years utilizing hanging factors in prisons that authorities knew about however didn’t take away, a Guardian investigation has discovered.
In a five-month overview of 248 hanging deaths in Australian jails, Guardian Australia recognized 19 correctional services the place inmates died after governments and authorities didn’t take away recognized ligature factors inside cells.
In lots of circumstances, this was regardless of repeated and pressing warnings from coroners to take action.
Households of the lifeless, former state coroners, justice reform consultants and former federal ministers have expressed their shock on the “astounding” failures of successive state governments to fulfil guarantees made after the royal fee into Aboriginal deaths in custody greater than 30 years in the past to take away such hanging factors.
Q&A
How had been deaths from ‘known ligature points’ counted?
Present
Guardian Australia has spent 5 months investigating the lethal toll of Australia’s inaction to take away hanging factors from its jails, a key suggestion of the 1991 royal fee into Aboriginal deaths in custody.
The principle discovering – that 57 inmates died utilizing recognized ligature factors that had not been eliminated – was made potential by an exhaustive examination of coronial data regarding 248 hanging deaths spanning greater than 20 years.
Reporters combed by way of giant volumes of coronial data searching for cases the place a dangling level had been used repeatedly in the identical jail.
They counted any loss of life that occurred after jail authorities had been made conscious of that individual hanging level. Warnings had been made through a previous suicide or suicide try, recommendation from their very own workers or suggestions from coroners and different impartial our bodies.
Guardian Australia additionally logged how most of the 57 inmates had been deemed vulnerable to self-harm or had tried suicide earlier than they had been despatched into cells with recognized hanging factors.
In adherence with finest apply in reporting on this matter, Guardian Australia has prevented detailed descriptions of suicide. In some cases, in order that the total ramifications of coronial suggestions will be understood, now we have made the choice to determine sorts and places of ligature factors. Now we have performed this solely in cases the place we really feel the general public curiosity on this data being accessible to readers is excessive.
The worst offender was Queensland’s Arthur Gorrie correctional centre, the place 10 prisoners killed themselves utilizing the identical kind of ligature level – uncovered bars that authorities knew about however didn’t take away.
The hangings continued till 2020 regardless of coronial warnings as early as 2007 that the state authorities “immediately make available sufficient funding to enable the removal of the exposed bars”. The identical coroner had informed authorities the bars “could easily be covered with mesh” following an earlier loss of life.
The identical failure was repeated throughout the state, at Townsville correctional centre, the place two inmates had been capable of cling themselves from recognized ligature factors, and at Ipswich’s Borallon correctional centre, the place two others died in an nearly an identical manner.
The issue shouldn’t be remoted to Queensland.
On the Darwin correctional centre cells had been outfitted with overhead fixtures that would bear physique weight, creating what coroners known as a “classic” hanging level. They had been utilized in two deaths inside two years of the jail’s opening in 2014 and weren’t fully eliminated till 2020.
In South Australia the Guardian discovered 14 deaths from hanging factors that had been recognized however not eliminated, together with on the Adelaide remand centre.
At the least 5 prisoners have hanged themselves from fixtures at Hakea jail in Western Australia, regardless of warnings to the state authorities as early as 2008 it ought to tackle all apparent ligature factors.
Sydney’s Lengthy Bay correctional complicated recorded 5 hangings from bars between 2000 and 2017, regardless of a warning in 2009 that the “obvious” hanging factors needed to be eliminated.
Throughout New South Wales the Guardian recognized 20 deaths from hanging factors recognized to authorities however not eliminated, together with at Goulburn, Parklea, Bathurst and Cessnock prisons.
after publication promotion
Guardian Australia requested each state authorities what has been performed to handle the issue. You possibly can learn their responses in full right here.
The revelations have prompted renewed requires motion from victims’ households.
Cheryl Ellis misplaced her son, Gavin, to suicide within the Darcy unit of the metropolitan remand and reception centre in Sydney’s Silverwater jail complicated in 2017.
The 31-year-old had a longstanding psychotic sickness and was a recognized suicide threat. In his first three days in custody he tried to hold himself twice however was not seen by a psychological well being clinician for eight days and was not reviewed by a psychiatrist for six weeks. He was despatched to a cell with a dangling level – a set of window bars. One other inmate had died by hanging from window bars within the Darcy unit two years earlier.
The bars remained within the unit cells after Gavin’s loss of life and had been utilized in a 3rd suicide in 2020. The inquest into Gavin’s loss of life beneficial that each one apparent hanging factors be eliminated however delays within the coronial system meant that suggestion didn’t come till two years after the third suicide.
The NSW authorities wouldn’t say whether or not the bars have now been eliminated.
Cheryl says her son ought to by no means have been despatched to that cell. She additionally says the hanging factors shouldn’t have been allowed to stay within the Darcy unit cells after Gavin’s loss of life. “The system does not have capital punishment yet it leaves hanging points for inmates to use,” she stated.
‘There can be no excuses’
Official information reveals suicide by hanging stays the most typical explanation for self-inflicted loss of life in custody. Appreciable progress was made to scale back the speed of hanging deaths within the late Nineteen Nineties and early 2000s. That progress has stalled since 2008, the information reveals.
The continued presence of recognized ligature factors is only one issue contributing to hanging deaths.
The 248 deaths investigated by the Guardian typically contain a number of failings, together with breakdowns in psychiatric assessments and a failure to supply correct psychological well being care, the shortage of appropriate beds in safe psychological well being services, the absence of correct statement regimes and errors in data sharing and cell placement.
Deaths in custody proceed to disproportionately have an effect on Indigenous Australians, who stay vastly overrepresented in jail populations. Seven Indigenous Australians hanged themselves in 2023-24, a quantity not recorded since 2000-01.
Robert Tickner, the previous Labor federal Indigenous affairs minister, led the Australian authorities’s response to the 1991 royal fee into Aboriginal deaths in custody. He helped to safe the settlement of state and territory governments to take away hanging factors from their prisons, one thing he describes as a “no brainer”.
“There can be no excuses for the failure to act,” he stated. “My very strong view is that the ultimate buck stops with the commissioners of corrections and governments.”
Michael Barnes, a former state coroner in Queensland and New South Wales, stated the variety of deaths from recognized ligature factors was “astounding”.
“It’s hard to think that it’s anything other than a lack of commitment that can explain the continuing high rate.”
